Canadians and Afghanistan
On Friday (November 3rd), more than 300 people stood outside in temperatures dipping below -6 C. in Edmonton, Alberta. Some wore poppies and others yellow ribbons. There was a group of children in red shirts enthusiastically singing "O Canada". This was not a peace rally, nor was it a political march. These people were standing freezing for over an hour recognizing the sacrifice of Canadian soldiers in an extremely controversial conflict, the fight for Afghanistan. "Years ago we didn't have this support," Master Cpl. Paul Franklin, a army medic wounded in Afghanistan by a suicide bomber, began. "But now when you go on missions you don't even have to think about how Canadians support us. We know. It's a given."
The number of Canadians in support of the war is just a bit over half (six out of ten) leaving this issue split in the opinion of the nation. Many believe that Canadians should not be involved in this war. That it is America's war. "I would think the majority of Canadians know that the troops have no say in why Canada is in Afghanistan -- it is the politicians trying to appease the Elephant to the South that brought us to Afghanistan," says an expatriate canadian now living in Atlanta. This is the opinion supported by many MP's on the left, including the liberal and new democratic parties and the Bloc-Quebecois. As of November 3rd, the Canadian casualties have reached 42, 13 of those soldiers being based in Edmonton. The opposition to the conflict grew much stronger when in May of 2006, Parliament, pushed vehemently by Prime Minister Stephen Harper, agreed to extend the length of Canada's responsibilities in Afghanistan until 2009. This came sudden and as a surprise to many Canadians, and those in opposition tend to feel as though Harper was pushing the act with too much speed and fervor to be considered reasonably thought through.
On the other side, the conservative government supports "staying the course" in Afghanistan until the mission is completed. The right tends to believe that we have an obligation to both our allies and the international community to fight the war on terrorism, and Afghanistan is very much a center of terrorist activity. In response to the accusations of American-influenced politics, the Conservative party denies any direct influence, yet admit that because of the close camaraderie of the two largest North American countries (who share the longest unprotected border in the world), there is quite a bit of trade and talk back and forth. The majority of Canadians do not support the government handling of the conflict, yet feel as though a direct pull out could be harmful to the country of Afghanistan. Many also just support the troops, no matter. "I have enough faith in my fellow countrymen to think that any Canadian would step in and stop the violence or tyranny and help the weak. If we choose to walk by, we condone the violence. If Canadians believe we should not help the weak, then let them stand up and say it. Otherwise step forward and loudly lend the troops your full support." (quote from letter from Canadian soldier overseas)
The War in Afghanistan is a controversial issue, one of the more talked about in Canada today. And as with many Americans, who find themselves torn between personal ethics and patriotism, Canadians find themselves asking, "Should we stay or should we go?"
http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Canada/2006/11/03/2220574-cp.html
http://www.torontosun.com/News/Columnists/Burnett_Thane/2006/11/03/2219907.html
http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/afghanistan/canada.html
